It’s Day 10 of our 13 Days of Christmas Cookies. Today’s recipe for Pappy’s Peanut Butter Cup Cookies comes from my great niece, Rebekah Green, and it’s one she made for my father every Christmas from the time she was old enough to bake. She made them alongside her mother, Malinda, and my sister, Linda, as they were the ones who first introduced my father to that delightful blend of peanut butter and chocolate.
I’m honestly not sure where the original recipe came from. It’s been through too many adjustments and variations over the years. But they’re easy to make with good basic ingredients. No fuss, just fun to eat. A little hard to bake, as it’s too tempting to eat them before they’re plated.