Iโ€™ve been on a pot pie kick lately. It started with some simple menu research. It seemed every other restaurant was offering some version of a pot pie.

The question was why… the easy answer was comfort food. But, was that right? Is it really comforting?

Max’s Original Chicken Pot Pie//Kay Logsdon

My research led to an ordering frenzy. Cheddarโ€™s. Chiliโ€™s. Cracker Barrel. KFC. Marie Callenderโ€™s. Lots and lots of independents, like the one pictured from Maxโ€™s Original near San Francisco โ€“ full of chicken, potatoes, carrots, celery, onions, peas, mushrooms and a delicious cream sauce. They each had their nuances, but the basics were the same: take fresh ingredients and mix them together, cover with flaky pastry and be transported back in time.

Truth is, the meal really is comforting, conjuring up the warmth and a great flavor, with a few memories here and there. I remember frozen pot pies, but I also remember some great years of living in Pennsylvania Dutch territory, where fresh pot pie is practically a staple. Iโ€™ve been known to buy Amish-made pot pie squares to make my own version of the classic comfort food, using a rotisserie chicken, some chicken stock and water, a bag of peas and carrots, with potatoes, a little half and half, and seasoningโ€”my version of โ€œhalfway homeโ€ cooking!

Autumnal Chicken Pot Pie
Autumnal Chicken Pot Pie//Lance Mellenbruch

If you see pot pie on the menu, donโ€™t resistโ€”give it a try and see what it feels like for you.

By the way, if you are wondering about the massive size of Maxโ€™s pot pie, yes, it was huge, and no, I couldnโ€™t eat more than half. Iโ€™m still dreaming, though, about the half I had to leave behind.

Especially when I need a little comfort.

Craving chicken pot pie now? Click here to get our favorite Autumnal Chicken Pot Pie recipe!

Publisher’s Corner is a weekly dive into the world of dining and food that you can find on foodchannel.com!

All Categories